For a new car key in Toronto, a dealer and a mobile car locksmith both cut and program keys, but they work differently. The dealer works on its own brand, in its own service bay, and often orders the key from the manufacturer by VIN. A mobile automotive locksmith brings the key machine and programming equipment to the car and makes the key in the same visit for most makes. Which is better depends on whether the car can be driven, how soon you need it, and whether your model is one of the few that only a dealer can do.
Dealer and mobile locksmith side by side
| Dealer | Mobile locksmith | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the car must be | At the dealer; towed if no key works | Wherever it is parked |
| Wait for the key | Same day to a week or more if the key is ordered | Usually made in the same visit |
| Makes covered | Its own brand | Most makes and models |
| Newest models | Always possible | Some are dealer-only |
| When you can get it done | Service department hours | Daily, 7am to 10:30pm |
When is the dealer the right call?
Go to the dealer if your model is dealer-only for keys, if a warranty or lease requires an original key from the dealer, or if the car is already booked in there for other work. Some newer European models and some very recent vehicles fall in the dealer-only group. We check your make, model and year when you call, and if the answer is the dealer, we tell you rather than send someone out.
When is a mobile locksmith the better call?
When no key works and the car would otherwise need a tow, when you need the car today, or when you just want a spare without booking a service appointment. The technician comes to the driveway, the street or the parking garage, and you test the key before the technician leaves.
Which one costs less?
A locksmith is often cheaper once towing and the wait are counted, but it depends on the car. We quote yours from the make, model and year before anyone is sent, so you can set it against a dealer quote for the same key.
Is a locksmith key original or aftermarket?
It can be either. Some drivers want the brand key for a lease return; others want the lower price of a good aftermarket key. Ask which one you are being quoted, and the price of each if your car takes both.
Dealer or locksmith: quick answers
Can the dealer cut a key without the car?
Some dealers can cut a blade from the VIN, but the chip or fob still has to be programmed to the car, so the car usually has to come in.
Can you make a key for a leased car?
Yes, with the lease paperwork or the ownership showing your name, plus photo ID.
What if a locksmith cannot do my car?
Then we say so on the phone and you go to the dealer. Nobody is sent to a car that cannot be done.
Does a locksmith key change how the car runs?
No. It is programmed through the same diagnostic port the dealer uses and only adds the key to the car's list.
Related pages
Not sure which way to go?
Call (416) 555-0150 with the make, model and year and get a straight answer.